Thus Spake An Inert Rebel

<>

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

How British are We?

I have always maintained that the national religion of post independence India is Britishism. We are often more British than the British themselves. This is actually true for a variety of reasons ranging from love for the white skin to a colonial hangover to plain inferiority complex. But there actually is more to our Britishism than what I imagined. The man who opened my eyes to how British we actually are was George Mikes. So here goes a passage from his omnibus, "How to be a Brit". The passage is the contents of a secret memo from the Ministry of Standstill(as Mikes calls the Transport Ministry) on how to go about road laying.

"Inasmuch as after seven or eight years of strenuous work, minor road-repairs must unfortunately be terminated, the cooperation of the local authorities is now sought. As soon as the road is covered by the new asphalt, but before it dries it is to be torn up again by the gas authorities; the same procedure is to be repeated by the Water Board authorities;by the telephone authorities; by the Sanitary authorities,by the Inland Revenue; by the local education authorities;by the Chelsea pensioners. As soon as the last-named body has completed operations, ordinary road-repairs may safely recommence."

Now we know why our corporation guys lay roads the way do. They are just being British.

If that is to do with the bureaucratic circles, this is what Mikes has to say about the intellectual achievements of the average British.

"A true-born Englishman does not know any language.......Indeed inability to speak foreign languages seems to be the major if not the only intellectual achievement of the average Englishman."

So our citizens are obediently practicing Britishism when they refuse to learn the language of the place they dwell in and instead continue to use Hindi or English or Tamil(as in Bangalore).
Now who dare question their right to the religion of their choice, a right enshrined in the Constitution?

PS: That line from Mikes reminds me of Cho's dialogue from Mohammed Bin Thuglaq...."Tamil Varathu, English Theriyathu, Hindi Pidikathu".

7 Comments:

At 10/5/07 14:50, Blogger Bala (Karthik) said...

We're also practising the Victorian Code Of Morality

 
At 10/5/07 19:35, Blogger mutRupuLLi said...

Very true Bala....Ibn Batutah in his travellogue of 14th-15th century remarks that South India society was one of the most immoral socities he had seen...Some portugese traveller writes the same abt people living in Vijayanagara...The moral code seems of the society seems to have offended them.........
But now we get offended for statements made by khushboo.....
Ithu therathu

 
At 11/5/07 13:50, Blogger Bala (Karthik) said...

"....Ibn Batutah in his travellogue of 14th-15th century remarks that South India society was one of the most immoral socities he had seen...Some portugese traveller writes the same abt people living in Vijayanagara"
- Actually its fascinating to read or realize that we were once a liberal, if not immoral/amoral society and we have changed so much (for the better, or for the worse).

There seems to be a conflict - two schools of thoughts about matters like this, the Aryan Invasion Theory etc..

One school seems to refute the AIT, accusing the Western 'scholars' of distorting history to suit their needs. What is your take on that? I haven't read much about this. Konjam velichatha veesunga pls...
[Maybe a separate post if you have the time/motivation]

P.S: "yenda poi Google panna vendiyadhu dhaane" nu neenga kekkalaam. Well, aah... aaaa.... :)

 
At 11/5/07 14:14, Blogger mutRupuLLi said...

aaha enna velichatha veesa sonnna muthal aaL...atharkkaga mikka nanri...:):)

Bala,....this Aryan invasion stuff and the arguments against are very complex and quite often i thnk it becomes a matter of personal ideology.....
The present take as far as i know is that the evidence for Aryan invasion is less conclusive than originally thought...And certainly the invasion of the kind the European historians thought is not supposed to be very likely......
But a lrge scale internal migration most likely happened......

We wouldnt know absolutely for sure what was the truth...and of course Sanksrit sources and Tamil sources are very problematic as the same words can mean a hell a lot of things in both these languages......and often these scholars would be just guessing at certain stuff..

Etho ennakku therinjathu.....but you can read the book "the invasion that never happened"....not unbiased but quite informative...

What is more interesting to me is the growth and comparisons of Tamil and Sanskrit...both very old and very different from outside but a linguist friend of mine says quie possibly that they evolved together in time and space..

 
At 11/5/07 14:55, Blogger mutRupuLLi said...

Bala..correction..
The book title is "Teh Invasion That Never Was"

 
At 11/5/07 14:56, Blogger mutRupuLLi said...

correction ke correction....:)
"The invasion that never was"........phew got it ok this time...

 
At 21/5/07 05:34, Blogger Bala (Karthik) said...

Sridhar,
Thanks for the info. Will check that book out...

 

Post a Comment

<< Home